Specializes In New York Style Pizza, Pasta and Salads

6744 NW 39th Expy, Bethany, OK 73008 (405) 491-6767

Our Story

We're blending our passion for making delicious food with our extensive knowledge of our cuisine to create authentic and classic dishes for your enjoyment. We use the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients and promise to give your taste buds something to be excited about.

Thank you for ordering directly from our website which helps us to provide the best service with a focus on top-quality ingredients. Enjoy your next meal to go—you will not be disappointed!

Special Offers

Available When You Order Online

•10% Off First Online Order

•$5 Off Every $100 Spent Online

Google Reviews

Kira Yagami

Best pizza in OKC! The food, service, and environment is excellent! I had a meatball & black olive pizza with their homemade Reaper sauce. By far the best spicy pizza I've ever had. It was the real deal. The flavor was amazing and the heat had me sweating like crazy.

Mike Knebel

My favorite Pizza in OKC (located in Bethany)! We dropped by and ordered a couple pizzas on Sunday. They were so good, we went back on Monday! Thanks Joe (owner) and Dianna (sp?) (owner)! The garlic knots are a must!

Juls Holloway

I will never buy pizza from anywhere but here. One it’s real pizza and the taste is phenomenal and the best, you can tell it’s homemade. I have a handicap mother in a wheelchair and EACH time I go a staff member stops and holds the door in and out, it helps so much and is such a sign of being vulnerable.

S.R.

Been eating here for years and the pizza is always consistently delicious! The BEST pizza for sure! The staff is always friendly and upbeat. I recently tried a special batch of their Eggplant Parmesan and it is seriously the BEST I ever had.

Dawson Zaugg

Great service, excellent staff, even better pizza!! Our choir group spent time here and I ordered a wonderful small cheese pizza with pepperoni and Italian sausage. It was absolutely delicious, I ate my plate in under 20 minutes.

Brandon Madl

Our first visit to Papa Angelo's was great. Excellent pizza and garlic knots. The staff was very friendly and welcoming. We had an Empire size pizza (20") and with three adults it was a plenty of food. My wife really enjoyed the chocolate cake as well.